What mechanism does the 'plasticity-first' hypothesis propose could simultaneously create specialized, less fertile females and fully developed females in an ancestral wasp?
Co-option of pre-existing phenotypic plasticity, such as seasonal diapause
The 'plasticity-first' hypothesis offers an explanation for the simultaneous emergence of caste differentiation, progressive provisioning, and nest-sharing in the ancestor of paper wasps and yellowjackets. This model suggests that the evolutionary change leveraged existing phenotypic plasticity within the ancestral stock. A prime example is a pre-existing mechanism for seasonal diapause (dormancy) found in bivoltine ancestors. If an external environmental cue, like the start of a cold season or severe resource limitation, triggered this established developmental switch, it could immediately sort the offspring cohort: those entering dormancy might become specialized, less fertile gynes (future queens), while others undergoing full development become the putative workers. This environmental accommodation precedes genetic reinforcement.

#Videos
Wasp Evolution - YouTube