What does the geographical separation between New World and Old World cichlids suggest about their common ancestor?
Answer
It likely existed before the complete breakup of Gondwana, or subsequent dispersal events were highly successful but isolated.
Analyzing the geographical split between Old World and New World cichlids implies deep biogeographical history, suggesting their shared ancestor existed prior to the full fragmentation of the supercontinent Gondwana, or that later dispersal events led to isolated evolution.

Related Questions
What is the family classification for cichlids?To which major order do cichlids belong?Approximately how many species are currently described within the Cichlidae family?Cichlids are confirmed members of which suborder?Which regions constitute the Old World distribution for cichlids?The immense speciation rate within the Cichlidae family is described as what evolutionary process?What class groups cichlids as ray-finned fishes?Cichlids are placed within the superorder encompassing many spiny-rayed fishes. What is this superorder?What does the geographical separation between New World and Old World cichlids suggest about their common ancestor?In some detailed classifications, cichlids are further placed within which infraorder?