What did the initial shared ancestry of the English Springer and Cocker Spaniel mean regarding their litters before formal separation?
A single litter could produce both larger and smaller dogs performing the same flushing work.
Because the ancestors of the Springer and Cocker Spaniels were grouped under the general 'Land Spaniels' umbrella without strict size separation initially, genetic variation within a single litter was common. Litters were not uniformly destined to be one breed or the other; rather, they could produce puppies of varying sizes. The smaller dogs in that litter would tend toward the Cocker specialization (flushing woodcock), while the larger ones would eventually develop into the Springer type. This shared, recent common ancestry explains why the genetic pool remained closely linked until the weight threshold was strictly enforced during registration processes in the late 19th century.
